Eyelid surgery or Botox for tired eyes: which one?

Tired eyes have three different causes

“Tired eyes” is how patients describe three different things: skin hooding the upper lid, bags under the eyes, and lines at the corners of the eyes and between the brows. Each has its own cause and its own treatment. Choosing between eyelid surgery and Botox starts with naming which one is there.

Skin hooding the upper lid: eyelid surgery

When skin folds down over the crease and onto the lashes, the problem is excess skin. Upper blepharoplasty removes it through an incision in the natural crease, together with fat where it is present. Botox removes no skin, so it cannot correct hooding (American Society of Plastic Surgeons).

Bags under the eyes: eyelid surgery

A bag under the eye is fat pushing forward behind the lower lid. Lower blepharoplasty treats that fat. Botox relaxes muscle; it does not change fat, and it does not flatten a bag.

Lines at the corners and between the brows: Botox

Crow’s feet and frown lines are made by muscle. Every smile and every frown folds the skin in the same place until the fold stays. Botulinum toxin relaxes the muscle that makes the line, so the line softens.

The effect begins at three to five days and is fully settled at 10 days, which is when the result is reviewed. It lasts three to four months at first. Eyelid surgery does not treat these lines: it works on the lid, not on the muscle around the eye.

Can Botox replace eyelid surgery?

No. Botox treats lines made by muscle. Excess eyelid skin and under-eye fat are removed surgically. Some patients have both planned — surgery for the lid, toxin for the crow’s feet — but one does not substitute for the other.

What neither one treats

• Dark circles from skin colour or thin skin. Eyelid surgery treats skin and fat, not colour (American Society of Plastic Surgeons).
• A low eyebrow. When the brow itself has dropped, the heaviness above the eye comes from the brow, and that is a separate question.
• Ptosis. A lid that sits low because the muscle that lifts it is weak is a different condition from excess skin, with a different operation.

A quick way to tell

• Skin resting on the lashes, eyes that look smaller than they used to → upper eyelid surgery.
• A bulge under the eye that shows in every photograph → lower eyelid surgery.
• Lines that appear when you smile or frown and fade when your face is still → Botox.

The examination confirms it. A photograph of someone else’s result is never the guide. Cases of both treatments are on the before-and-after page.

Questions

FAQ

Sources

• American Society of Plastic Surgeons — Eyelid Surgery
• American Society of Plastic Surgeons — Botulinum Toxin
• NHS — Eyelid surgery
• StatPearls (NCBI Bookshelf) — Upper Eyelid Blepharoplasty
• StatPearls (NCBI Bookshelf) — Lower Eyelid Blepharoplasty
• StatPearls (NCBI Bookshelf) — Botulinum Toxin Treatment of the Upper Face

← Eyelid surgery · Botox and filler →